During
Mark Scott, Managing Director, ABC, talk at the
Innovative Ideas Forum 2009, I did a
quick check and the ABC's new mobile web site which showed accessibility and HTML validation problems. Mr. Scott said he thought the accessibility problems had been fixed and he would go back to the office and check. To assist, here are some details on the test results.
I ran a TAW (Web Accessibility Test) based on the
W3C -
Web Content Accessibility Guidelines 1.0 (
WCAG 1.0). This reported 0 Priority 1, 14 Priority 2 and 1 Priority 3 automated test problems. While there were no Priority 1 automated errors, manual inspection requests were flagged, such as:
- Suspicious text equivalent for image, can not be file name or file size or placeholder text (1)
- Line 32:
In this case the alternate text for someone who can't see images is the word "image". This is not useful text and appears to have been inserted so as to trick the automated test process. Other inappropriate ALT text appears to be honest mistakes by an inadequately trained web designer
:alt='White Space'
The
W3C Markup Validator reported 79 errors. Many of these errors were due to unencoded ampersands and are not serious problems and easily fixed. More serious is that no "Doctype" is specified so it is not clear which particular HTML standard is intended. The document seems to be a mix of different pieces of HTML pasted from different sources. The validation assumed
XHTML 1.0 Transitional, but I was unable to find any setting for which the code passed validation.
Most desktop web browsers will accept invalid code most of the time. However, mobile phone browsers tend to be more sensitive and may produce no useful display. Adaptive technology used by people with a disability will tend to be more sensitive and so may not work. Also it is not a good idea to hope the web pages will display correctly when communicating emergency information.
The ABC should be using tools to check the web pages are technically correct. They should also ensure the staff using the tools are trained in how to design web pages. Labels: Blogs, iif2009, Innovative Ideas Forum, NLA, twitter