Perspectives on the Telecommunications Reform Package

ACS Telecommunication Society of Australia (ACS-TSA)

For the ATUG Focus Forum, Canberra, 14 October 2009

These are noted for the Australian Telecommunications Users Group (ATUG) is hosting "Focus Forum on 2009 Telecommunications Reform Package. This version of the presentation was prepared by Tom Worthington FACS HLM.

The forum will also be at other cities:

NBN Initiative

Platform and enabler for participation in the digital economy
Visionary: addressing Australia's inadequate investment in BB infrastructure
Also addresses inadequate regulation of market power in wholesale and retail markets
But what the NBN will deliver is not clear.

The high level issues

What will be the NBN's wholesale service?
What will be its guaranteed QoS?
NBN and national wholesale pricing?
Will the NBN serve IPTV providers with network neutrality?
How can transparency be achieved in the NBN's business practices?
Should an Industry Ombudsman be created for NBN retail performance issues?
What transitional arrangements and competitive protections?
Will competitors to the NBN really be permitted or even safeguarded?

What will be the NBN's wholesale service?

At least three components:

Implementation service
Transmission capability: point-to-point with guaranteed QoS re performance: bandwidth, outages etc
Maintenance service

What will be the guaranteed QoS?

Essential for the NBN to offer minimum guaranteed service levels for all service aspects within its (implementation, transmission, maintenance) to provide a basis on which retail service providers can offer QoS to their end customers, especially business customers.

Can the NBN offer multiple SLAs? Can it actually deliver a range of SLAs?
The realities of service bottlenecks in international links can be allowed for in service agreements

NBN and national wholesale pricing?

Costs vary with geography & density
- Sparse population - high 'backhaul' costs
- Low population densities
Elements of the solution
- Multiple platforms : FTTP for 90%, advanced wireless and satellite for 10%
- Multiple POIs
- Backhaul 'network'
- Cross subsidy within NBN

Will the NBN offer network neutrality?

Network Neutrality (NN): no differentiation by the NBN in terms of price or performance by content source:

Essential for competition
Allows competition in IPTV services
Requires a QoS supporting IPTV

Transparency in the NBN business?

NBN Co needs a transparent policy decision process:

Publishing all Board decisions after each meeting (ICANN model)
Industry Ombudsman

Is a new industry Ombudsman needed?

Current Telecommunications Industry Ombudsman (TIO) deals with consumer complaints.
Industry Ombudsman Office needed for complaints by NBN customers (ICANN's Ombudsman).

Transitional arrangements and protections

What transitional arrangements and competitive protections will apply for service providers using current networks?

Other Perspectives

Will competitors to the NBN really be permitted or even safeguarded?
Will the NBN operate during a bushfire?
Is Transact a model for the NBN, with some FTTP in apartment blocks
Will the NBN be accompanied by funding to use it for national priorities in Social Inclusion, Employment, Education and the Environment?

More Information

Slides for these notes are also available.